Thursday, August 23, 2007

Recycling. Aluminum: good. Glass: bad.

I'm listening to a couple of economists talk about recycling. The conversation was humorous and entertaining, and I found two bits of it really interesting:

First, a prediction by Prof. Munger that in 100 years we will see strip-mining of old landfills to recover plastic (which we'll burn to produce energy, since oil will be very expensive by then). I agree; I think old landfills will be a great very-long-term investment, there's all sorts of good stuff in there that is currently too expensive to recover and reuse. But in 100 years, I bet we'll have the technology to efficiently extract all sorts of valuable stuff from old garbage dumps (if the history nuts will let us; maybe they'll all be declared "archeologically valuable" and put off-limits).

Second, insights into the "recycling religion." Some environmentalists put an essentially infinite value on "Virgin Mother Earth." It doesn't matter what the cost is to recycle (of human time, energy, water, ...), in their view it is ALWAYS worth it to recycle rather than "take precious, irreplaceable resources from Mother Earth." Recycling has become Religion, and we're judged by our neighbors if we don't go along with the Holy Rites and put our bright blue and red containers by the curb with our trash.

News flash: paper comes from trees that are grown for that purpose, just like we grow wheat to make bread. Glass comes from sand. Sand comes from rocks. And rocks are being created all the time.


Richard Morse said...

Where is the evidence that supports the contention that "recycling has become religion"? Huh? I like your overarching sense of skepticism about all of life around you, Gavin, but this paragraph was ridiculous. I guess that you have this "live and let live" mentality that makes all possible debate about personal responsibility unnecessary and even coercive.

I travel to other parts of the country and the recycling effort in most places between the coasts is still nearly invisible.

This may be the single dumbest thing that I've seen posted on your blog. Which means, of course, that I'll keep reading.

Gavin Andresen said...

Thanks for the kind words!

As for recycling being religion: Ok, that's an exaggeration. But others have noticed the same similarity to recycling and religious faith; see:

Anonymous said...

This blog is ingenious and i have beeen looking for someone to agree with me on this subject for a very long time.
I needed some views of others who were on my side of the debate/speech I have to present in my 9th grade Advanced Language Arts class and you are my saving grace.
Once again, thank you so much